Loading ...
Loading ...

Poor quality a clue to new cast ironBy

Poor quality a clue to new cast iron

Lots of new cast iron is being copied from period originals, especially Art Deco and Art Nouveau figures. Most of these new pieces, like the candlestick shown here, can be detected by poor quality construction. Feet and hands are particularly good keys to quality because they require sharp detail to appear realistic. New pieces in more complicated shapes are often made in several pieces and welded together. The welded sockets on this new candlestick, for example, are very awkwardly positioned.

image

Fig. 1 New Art Nouveau figural lady 8½ inch cast iron candlestick. Finished in dull gold to imitate bronze.

image

Fig. 2 The candle socket is cast separately and welded to the head. Note the strange tilting position.

image

Fig. 3 Detail of badly blurred and pitted feet on the new cast iron candlestick. Hands and feet are excellent general indicators of overall quality. Poorly formed fingers and toes are almost always a warning sign of poor construction.

Real Or Repro is powered by Ruby Lane — the award-winning marketplace trusted by collectors worldwide.

Why Ruby Lane? Winner of multiple Ecommerce Bytes Sellers Choice Awards for Quality, Customer Service, and Most Recommended Selling Venue.

Now that you know what to avoid...

♥️ Find the Real Deal on Ruby Lane

Shop with confidence from our vetted dealers who specialize in authentic vintage and antique treasures.
Vintage Queen Cast Iron Toy Stove
The Vintage Crate
$110
Cast Iron "Sad Iron" Letter C Iron
Treasure Hut
$50
Eclipse Cast Iron Salesman Sample Stove
Oldeclectics
$361
$379
Victorian Style Cast Iron Lion Face Legs, Pair
Classic Fab Finds
$225
Made In USA Cast Iron Popover Pan
Colemans Collectibles
$76
Antique Small Cast Iron Ives Toy Cap Gun
Patricia Funt Antiques
$165
$185
Cast Iron "Sad Iron" #7 Clothes Iron
Treasure Hut
$75
Original Vintage Hubley Cast Iron Scottish Terrier Door Stop
The Vintage Crate
$475
Hubley Setter Cast Iron Doorstop
Avenue Art and Antiques
$185
Vintage Cast Iron Kettle
Fenwood Studio
$45
Cast Iron Horse Dinner Bell
Twin Pines Estate Sales
$53
$55
Wagner's 100th Anniversary Cast Iron Set
Oldeclectics
$125
Antique vintage IRON for ironing in cast iron hand made Original from 1940s Made in Italy
Valandiashop
~$82
Cast iron treasure chest bank
Harmon Antique Sales.
$40
Vintage Cast Iron Nut Cracker "OLD DOG TRAY"
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$65
Antique German Cast Iron Heart Shaped Waffle Iron High Ring Handles 19th Century
Thomas L Stewart
$250
$399
Vintage Griswold #6 Large Block Logo Cast Iron Skillet 699
The Vintage Crate
$140
Vintage Cast Iron Sleigh and Victorian Style Lady, Hurley Manufacture Co.
Midnight Carousel Antiques
$695
Cast iron squirrel nutcracker
Harmon Antique Sales.
$72
Large cast iron lion bank
Harmon Antique Sales.
$100
The Clue of the Broken Locket - Nancy Drew Mystery Stories
Big-Little Book Emporium
$12
Cast iron turtle with hinged lid
Harmon Antique Sales.
$27
19th Century Eastlake Cast Iron Inkwell
Why? Why Not
$210
Antique Victorian Cast Iron Articulated 12 Plant Stand
The Old Light Warehouse
$900
$1,150
Victorian Gilt Cast Iron Picture Frame
Patricia Funt Antiques
$95
Vintage Cast Iron Frog Flower Frog
Carolena's Vintage Collectables
$85
Vintage Cast Iron Duck Doorstop
Yellow Garage Antiques Market
$186
Vintage Pair of Brass Toned Cast Iron Clipper Ships Book Ends
Shades of the Past
$48
Cast iron ship bookends marked Constitution
Harmon Antique Sales.
$22
Hubley cast iron puppo
Harmon Antique Sales.
$94
Cast Iron Bear Candlestick Figure
Gumgumfuninthesun
$28
19th Century American Cast Iron Dayton Malleable Iron Works Shop Torch
Fritz Antiques
$225
Antique Original Enterprise Cast Iron Coffee Grinder- Model No. 7
The Vintage Crate
$1,090
Amish Buggy and Family Cast Iron Toy
Great Finds
$75
Hubley cast iron wrecker
Harmon Antique Sales.
$98
Porcelain cast iron bath rack, c.1910s
Residential Relics
$395
Hubley cast iron scottie dog
Harmon Antique Sales.
$115
Cast iron pointer dog statue
Harmon Antique Sales.
$58
Cast iron seated rabbit bank
Harmon Antique Sales.
$130
Painted Cast Iron Parrot Figure
Yellow Garage Antiques Market
$444
Early Original Cast Iron Bulldog Doorstop
Yellow Garage Antiques Market
$444
1896-1910 Lodge Blacklock No.7 Cast Iron Sad Iron
Shades of the Past
$60
Vintage Cast Iron Rococo Picture Frame
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$40
Vintage Findlay No.3 Cast Iron Frying Pan
The Vintage Crate
$150
Arcade cast iron and glass "crystal bank"
Harmon Antique Sales.
$98
Cast Iron Painted Hunters Match Safe
Avenue Art and Antiques
$168
Arcade Red 221 R Cast Iron Toy Truck
Antique World USA
$175
Smith & Egge “Little Comfort” Cast Iron Chain Drive Sewing Machine c.1896
The Vintage Crate
$530
Cast iron Singer No.20 sewing machine
Harmon Antique Sales.
$168
Cast Iron Plumb Bob Vintage Tool
Hardscrabble Tools
$21
1900's Victorian Cast Iron Dog Embossed Drawer Pull
Glory Bee Estate Finds
$12
Vintage “Clue Game” Revolver Game Piece
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$9
Wilkins cast iron horse drawn cart
Harmon Antique Sales.
$148
Antique Primitive Cast Iron Stove Finial, Humidor, Urn, Hearth Accessory
Neatcurios
$125
Antique Cast Iron Folding Stove or Warming Shelves, Primitive, Country
Neatcurios
$145
Cast Iron Horse Drawn Fireman Ladder Wagon
Paths Before You
$90
$95
The Clue in the Diary - Nancy Drew Mystery Stories
Big-Little Book Emporium
$17
Antique original early 1900's Uncle Moses cast iron coin still bank Americana
Dusty Treasures
$339
$490
Cast iron rooster bank
Harmon Antique Sales.
$150
Vintage Miniature Cast Iron "QUEEN" Stove - Salesman Sample / Toy
Sabre's Antique Store
$38
Antique Acme Cast Iron Stove Salesman Sample
Corky's Antiques
$375
Cast iron buffalo bank
Harmon Antique Sales.
$98
Young America Cast Iron Coin Bank
Avenue Art and Antiques
$75
Cast Iron Sheep Piggy Bank
Classic Fab Finds
$19
Antique Cast Iron School Bell with Clapper, Unknown Age
Laureate Antiques
$245
Man in the Moon Cast Iron Crescent Pin Tray
BeJewelled
$150
Hubley Cast Iron Wire Fox Terrier Bookends
Avenue Art and Antiques
$165
Griswold Cast Iron Aebleskiver
Avenue Art and Antiques
$120
Hubley cast iron woodpecker doorknocker
Harmon Antique Sales.
$125
Cast Iron Art Deco Lighted Christmas Tree Stand
Copperton Lane Antiques and Collectibles
$125
Cast iron elephant bank
Harmon Antique Sales.
$65
Stover Jr. Cast Iron Toy Waffle Maker
J Mikalson Antiques and Decorative Arts LLC
$65
Antique 19thC Cast Iron Cherub Angel, Architectural, Garden Decor
Neatcurios
$195
Antique Circa 1880s Victorian Cast Iron, Wall Mount Card Holder
Neatcurios
$75
Hubley cast iron airplane
Harmon Antique Sales.
$135
Swirling Woman Art Nouveau Cast Iron Pin Tray
BeJewelled
$198
Vintage Patchen Cast Iron Head Horse Weathervane.
Treasure Hunter
$3,200
Antique German Muller #95996 Cast Iron Toy Sewing Machine
Oldeclectics
$165
Cast Iron Garden Fence with Spikes by Relax Days
My Grandmother Had One
$90
$100
Antique Hubley #22 Cast Iron Toy Race Car W/ Driver
Oldeclectics
$125
Cast iron scottie dog doorstop
Harmon Antique Sales.
$148
Italian Studio 1960s Brutalist Iron Candlesticks Set 12.5"
Lamps & Lagniappe
$386
$575
Albany Foundry Cast Iron Tulips Doorstop
LB Antiques and Design
$128
Goberg Hammered Iron Cat Candlestick w/ Smoking Attachments
Sweetpea Cottage
$469
Wagner's 1891 Cast Iron Miniature Square Skillet Limited Edition
Gumgumfuninthesun
$32
19th Century Italian Cast Iron Garden Statues, a Pair
Olivier Fleury, Inc. - French Antiques
$950
Lyre-Harp Cast Iron Holder
Classic Fab Finds
$24
Hubley French Bulldog Cast Iron Door Stop with Original Paint
The Vintage Crate
$450
Cast Iron Double Snail Inkwell & Pen Holder
Avenue Art and Antiques
$148
Miniature Boston Terrier Cast Iron Hubley Figurine
Time's Treasures Railroad & Country
$38
$49