Loading ...
Loading ...

Figural matchsafe updateBy

Figural matchsafes

New figural sterling matchsafes are available at shows, malls and Internet auction sites. This new group does not have the DAB touchmark or correct English hallmarks to identify and date them as new. All of the new safes are copies of well known and relatively expensive originals.

Four of the most commonly seen new silver figurals are Toby dog, Punch, owl and devil head. Generally, quality is low with badly fitting lids, lack of detail, poorly finished seams and incorrect strikers. The striker on the owl, for example, is applied. Virtually all original strikers were formed as an integral part of the safe, not applied. The other new strikers have very narrow deep grooves as seen in Figs. 4 & 5 below. Although old strikers bear a general resemblance to each other, very few are exactly alike. If the strikers are identical on a number of different safes, be suspicious.

One of the key identifying features of the new safes is the .925 silver mark. This mark was rarely used on genuinely old safes, but is used almost exclusively on new safes. On some new safes, the word "sterling" has been added to the .925 mark (Fig. 4). Although sterling was certainly used on old safes, .925 and sterling rarely appeared together.

Many new marks and strikers are manufactured intentionally blurred to give the appearance of age and wear. In some cases fake hallmarks are applied to suggest English manufacture (Fig. 4). On close inspection the shield-shaped hallmarks are perfectly blank without any proper markings. How can you tell if a mark is worn by natural use or made new? Easy. Any mark worn smooth by natural wear will show numerous scratches running through the mark. New pieces manufactured as "worn" are smooth with no scratches, they've never been subject to normal use.

A fifth figural safe, lady on chamber pot, is silver plated brass (Figs. 1). The inside is a frosted gray color which is also typical of the sterling safes. The original of this shape is only known in brass. If the original were plated, it was most likely nickel. Virtually all original plated safes were nickel plated, not silver plated. Some areas of the silver plating on the new safe have been deliberately ground away to shown the brass below as if by natural wear.

The reproduction lacks the handle found on the original. Old and new lids are also hinged differently and open in opposite directions. The new lid is hinged and opens from the back of the chamber pot. The old lid is hinged and opens from near the front of the chamber pot.

All the safes shown here were purchased in England. Prices ranged $29 to $41 except for the lady on chamber pot which was $85.

Thanks to George Sparacio for his comments and loaning these matchsafes for photography.

image

Fig. 1

image

Fig. 2

image

Fig. 3

image

Fig. 4 The "hallmark" on left and .925 at right arrow are intentionally manufactured smooth to suggest wear and age. Deep striker groove runs through center.

image

Fig. 5 This new safe includes both .925 mark and word "sterling". The .925 mark, even though it appears with sterling, is almost always a sign of a reproduction. Striker identical to Fig. 1.

image

Fig. 6 Toby dog. Very heavy cast piece, a little over 2" high. Marked 925 and sterling. Obvious grinding marks on heavy cast lid.

image

Fig. 7 Traditional Punch figure. Heavy cast piece. Marked .925 and sterling, 2¼".

image

Fig. 8 Devil head, 1½". Imitation hallmark and .925 are stamped very faintly to suggest wear (Fig. 3). Poor fitting lid. Red glass eyes are glued in, glue fluoresces under black light.

image

Fig. 9 Owl, 1¾", marked .925 and sterling. Red glass eyes bezel set. Striker and marks are very "worn" to simulate age.

image

Fig. 10 The striker on the new owl's head is applied. Although this is not typical, some original safes also have applied strikers so this is not a definite test of age.

Real Or Repro is powered by Ruby Lane — the award-winning marketplace trusted by collectors worldwide.

Why Ruby Lane? Winner of multiple Ecommerce Bytes Sellers Choice Awards for Quality, Customer Service, and Most Recommended Selling Venue.

Now that you know what to avoid...

♥️ Find the Real Deal on Ruby Lane

Shop with confidence from our vetted dealers who specialize in authentic vintage and antique treasures.
Antique Gorham Sterling Silver Match Safe
Pigeon Squared
$195
Vintage Sterling Silver Mermaid Match Safe, Vesta, Pocket Matchsafe
Neatcurios
$145
Victorian Sterling Silver Vesta Match Safe
Suzy Lemay
$145
Art Nouveau Sterling Silver Vesta Case Match Box Safe Chatelaine Birmingham Fob Antique 1900
David Lesurf Antiques and Art
$245
Antique Art Nouveau Coin Silver Match Safe Vesta
Carolena's Vintage Collectables
$175
French Antique Victorian Silver Engraved Vesta Match Safe
Suzy Lemay
$175
Antique Pairpoint Silverplate Palmer Cox Brownie Match Safe, Toothpick
Neatcurios
$75
RARE Victorian Dublin Irish Sterling Silver & Connemara Marble Three Leaf Clover Match Safe Vesta Case - Joseph Cook & Son
Evening Moon Antiques
$875
European Art Nouveau 800 Silver Vesta or Match Safe
Suzy Lemay
$195
Antique 1887 Victorian Sterling Silver & Glass Match Striker- John Grinsell & Sons
ApexLyon Antiques
$1,100
$1,500
Antique STERLING Art Nouveau Daisy Match Safe / Vesta Case - Flower Design
Jewelpigs
$125
French Antique Silver Plated Joan of Arc Vesta or Match Safe
Suzy Lemay
$125
Antique Victorian JMB British Sterling Vesta Match Safe With Matches
Carolena's Vintage Collectables
$175
Victorian Sterling Silver Match Safe
Pigeon Squared
$175
Sterling Match Safe Christmas 1895
Victoriental
$140
Art Nouveau Nude Nymph VESTA Match Safe, Watrous
Arnold Jewelers
$495
Antique Victorian Sterling Silver Vesta Match Safe
53 Court
$95
French Art Nouveau Silver Vesta Match Safe - Charles Murat
Suzy Lemay
$225
Victorian Sterling Silver Finely Etched Repousse Vesta Match Safe Case
Vintage Vistas
$145
German Jugendstil 800 Silver Vesta or Match Safe
Suzy Lemay
$645
Rare Novelty Silver and Glass Match Striker, Dates to 1905
Perry-Joyce Fine Arts
$175
$395
Fabulous Antique Jugenstil/Wiener Werkstatte Design Cigarette Card Case: Matching Miniature Match Striker to Wear
Duchess Arts & Antiques
$995
Antique Sterling Silver Match Safe – John Gilbert & Co. Birmingham 1902 – Hand Chased Vesta Case
Nicer Than New
$124
19th Century Sterling Match Safe Vesta
treasuresRtimeless
$299
$325
1800's Victorian Silver Plate Match Safe Wish Bone Toothpick Holder Stand Figural Best Wishes
Antique Matchmaker
$56
$69
Sterling Silver Vesta Safe Birmingham 1909
Emporium, Ltd.
$375
Silver Horseshoe Design Match Safe Vesta
Antiquefreak's
$125
Victorian Sterling Cupid and Psyche Match Safe
Victoriental
$169
Antique Sterling Silver Match Safe c.1901- H.Huntly +Sons
The Vintage Crate
$125
Art Nouveau Vesta Match Safe Mermaid Frolicking Women Wm. Kerr Sterling Silver
Arnold Jewelers
$695
Handsome Mark Cross Silverplate Hinged Box - Mid Century
Patricia Funt Antiques
$159
Antique Ceramic and Sterling Silver Match Striker
AC Silver
~$1,712
Vintage Judaica Dutch solid Sterling silver Marked Jewish Torah pointer or Yad
La Tresorerie
~$717
70 Piece Vintage Older Mark Georg Jensen Sterling Acorn Pattern Flatware Set how
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$9,000
Birks Sterling Silver Ring Box Marked Birks Sterling
The Vintage Crate
$295
Antique Glass and Sterling Silver Match Striker
AC Silver
~$1,514
Sterling Silver Vesta Match Safe dated 1911
Emporium, Ltd.
$200
Antique Victorian Glass and Sterling Silver Match Striker
AC Silver
~$1,712
English Sterling Match Safe Vesta Case Fob 1904
Mendocino Vintage
$154
Antique Glass and Sterling Silver Match Striker (1913)
AC Silver
~$1,448
Antique Alabaster, Lapis Lazuli and Sterling Silver Match Striker
AC Silver
~$1,712
Antique Gilbert Sterling Silver Match Safe Vesta Case with Monogram #21300
Gold and Silver Brokers
$260
Gorham Sterling Match Safe / Vesta, Art Nouveau, Antique 1909
Lake Girl Vintage
$275
Sterling Silver Chatelaine Waist Plaque with Knife, Photo Ball, Hook, Pencil and Match Safe
Brass Pineapple Antiques and Estates
$690
S Kirk and Son antique sterling silver Squirrel animal miniature figure figurine
ArtNotch
$530
Sterling Silver-Handled Carving Fork with 3 marks Crown/W/Lion *
AL Silver - "Estate Silver"
$39
Mark J. Scearce Sterling Silver Gerald R Ford Mint Julep Cup w/Monogram #21026
Gold and Silver Brokers
$1,327
Vintage ornate sterling silver 925 figural cherub putti picture photograph frame
Dusty Treasures
$659
$750
Antique STERLING Flower & Flourishes Match Safe / Vesta Case - Baroque Design
Jewelpigs
$125
Glass and Sterling Silver Match Striker Antique
AC Silver
~$1,514
5 Sterling Salt Spoons Figural Japanese
Arlene Rabin Antiques
$65
Art Nouveau Figural Nude Sterling Nail Cleaner
Studio Juliano
$125
Sterling Silver Spoon with Native American Figure
Patricia Funt Antiques
$75
King Richard Lemon Fork by Towle marked Sterling Silver *
AL Silver - "Estate Silver"
$45
Art Nouveau 10K Yellow Gold Match Safe Vesta
AntiqueJewelryNyc
$2,175
Antique Repousse Sterling Silver Match Safe d.1898 (20g)
Brian Alan - Antiques and Fine Art
$79
Vanity tray - Bread plate - Serving tray by International Silver Co. marked Sterling Silver Production #3686 *
AL Silver - "Estate Silver"
$365
Set(6) Gorham Strasbourg Sterling Demitasse Spoons Early 1897 Factory Mark
Grandview Fine Tableware
$239
Biedermeier antique silver salt cellars, marked 1839
Chateau Antique
$560
Sterling Aladdin Lamp of Learning Cigar Table Lighter by Marks & Cohen c.1910
Paths Before You
$350
Figural mermaid envelope/card holder
The R & J Collection
$250
$350
Silver Plated Vesta Case / Match Safe For Chatelaine
Brass Pineapple Antiques and Estates
$68
Antique Victorian Frosted Glass and Sterling Silver Match Striker
AC Silver
~$1,910
Sterling TEA POT / Kettle Figural Tea Infuser - Signed Amcraft - Teapot
Jewelpigs
$95
Carter, Gough Co. Sterling Match Safe - C. 1900
Richard W. Bell
$195
Antique Edwardian Scarce Masonic Vesta Case / Match Safe Sterling Silver 1903
Evening Moon Antiques
$1,125
Antique Edwardian Sterling Silver Match Safe Vesta Case Chatelaine
Vintage Vistas
$185
Antique Original Judaica Silver Kiddish Cup Vienna כוס צפתית Safed Signed Jewish
Zakai Gallery
$749
Antique German Sterling Silver Musician Table Figures/Goblets 1900
AC Silver
~$34,306
Exceptional Antique Gorham Versailles Gravy Ladle Copyright Mark
Grandview Fine Tableware
$325
Georgian Silver Sterling Large Round Cake Basket with Swing Handle Mark of Paul Storr, London
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$6,980
American Federal Colonial Coin Silver Serving Spoon, Monogrammed, Marked BV
Fritz Antiques
$300
Art Nouveau Sterling Silver Match Safe, Early F. S. Gilbert
treasuresRtimeless
$350
$395
Antique 1800's Sterling Silver Tested Marked Mechanical Pencil American Works
Nobelantique
$575
Interesting set of eight sterling coffee spoons with Yukon figural handles
Sterling Island
$262
$275
Naughty Nude” Art Nouveau Sterling Silver Figural Lady Cocktail Fork – Rare German Hanau c.1900–1910
Antiques Etc
$129
$135
Special antique 1860-1880 marked French sterling Silver Polichinelle baby rattle with whistle & bells / by French bebe doll
La Tresorerie
~$436
Vintage Solid Sterling Silver Peruvian Figural Pendant Rare Big Hefty
GreatVintageStuff
$265
Antique French Silver Napkin Ring Minerva 1 Mark
Appaloosa Antiques
$185
Ornate sterling silver Napkin Ring Serviette Holder by Gorham date Mark for 1883 engraved Willie
Hill Country Galleries
$159
Victorian figural ink blotters
The R & J Collection
$490
Vintage Reed & Barton Sterling POINTED ANTIQUE Flat Handled Punch Ladle, Early Mark
Grandview Fine Tableware
$599
Vintage Sterling Scissors Handle Grapes and Fox Marked
Cabinets of Curiosity
$120
Antique silver enamelled peacock figure, Vienna ,19th century
Chateau Antique
$890
Battin & Co. Sterling Mistress Match Safe / Matchsafe - C. 1900
Richard W. Bell
$395
Figural Hatpin Holder or Match Holder, Fox with Umbrella
Arlene Rabin Antiques
$210
Sterling Silver Tea Strainer Figural Fishnet
Arlene Rabin Antiques
$135
Beautiful Vintage SILVER GRAPE Shears, Grape SCISSORS Figural Handles,Ornate Silver,Fine Dining,French Country Decor,Collectible Vintage Silver
Vintage Things
$145
Victorian Sliver plated figural jewelry box
The R & J Collection
$675
$875
Antique 14ct Yellow Gold and Enamel Spark Striker Circa 1920
AC Silver
~$2,029