Reproductions in motionBy Sam and Anna Samuelian
Reproductions in motion
a report on new animated motion lamps
Motion lamps are a type of novelty lighting with moving, or animated, scenes. The motion is created by a cylinder in the center of the lamp which turns powered by air rising above the warm electric bulb.
The new lamps that will probably cause the most problems are five copies of highly sought after scenic designs originally made in the mid-1950s by an American company named Econolite. These include a locomotive, early auto, sailing ships, water mill and aquarium. The new lamps are made in India and retailed for about $30-$40 each. Econolite originals of comparable designs sell for $225-$350.
Before discussing the differences, let's look at similarities between new and old. First, the new Econolite-styled lamps are the same height and same oval shape (as viewed from above) as many of the company's originals made in the late fifties and early sixties. The oval shape allowed for a wider surface area for the design and created a panoramic effect. Original oval lamps are generally more desirable and harder to find than their round counterparts so the reproductions copy the best shape of the vintage pieces.
New shades are made of plastic similar to the old in color and thickness. New cylinders are very close to the same size as originals. Slight size differences between new and old are not meaningful because many original cylinders have shrunk slightly from heat and age. New cylinder tops are metal and have twelve fan blades, the same as originals.
On original scene sleeves the printing is identical on both side. This created richer color when the lamp was turned on. Both sides of reproduction scene sleeves are also printed but they are not identical. Only the most important parts of the new design are repeated; coloring on the ship, for example, but not the surrounding water.
The most obvious difference is between tops and bottoms which support the inner and outer sleeves of the shade. New tops and bottoms are a light yellow plastic; original tops and bottoms are cardboard (Fig. 5). Air circulation holes in new shades appear hand cut and a bit rough; holes are smooth in old. There are also four tiny air holes in new tops and bottoms in addition to the large central hole. The tiny holes are not found on original tops and bottoms. New shades have a shiny surface; surface of old shades is matte finish.
Next, the bases are very different. New lamps are supported by rather plain, one-piece black plastic bases with four molded feet (Fig. 3). All original Econolite lamps are on brass plated metal bases with a pierced linked chain-type pattern. The original bases rest on three ball-shaped feet (Fig. 4).
New lamps have no identifying marks. Original Econolite lamps have copyright information printed on most of their cylinders, animation sleeves and scene sleeves. New lamps have two seams in the animation sleeve, originals have only one seam. Graphics printed on the new animation sleeves are all blue. Graphics printed on old animation sleeves are always either white or gray.
Graphics on new cylinders are mostly black; on old cylinders the graphics are primarily white. The seam on old cylinders is diagonal which creates a smooth flowing animation. Seams on new cylinders are vertical. As the new cylinder rotates, the vertical seam can be detected as a slight visual "blip" on the outer scene.
Old cylinders are supported by a single metal rod angled out over the bulb (Fig. 4). New cylinders are supported by an arch shaped metal harp (Fig. 3). The new harps are adjustable up and down; the only adjustment to old support rods was bending by hand.
Switches in new lamps are wired into the power cord. Switches on old lamps are built into the bases.
Finally, all the new lamps have very bright, rich colors. Even a mint in the box original does not have the color intensity of the new reproductions. Although the new shades are brighter, they lack the fine detail and tonal gradation found in the originals. For detailed comparisons of individual models, refer to the captions that accompany the photos.
In addition to reproductions of classic oval lamps from the 1950s, later motion lamps made up until the 1980s are also back in production. These lamps, called Op (short for optical) or psychedelic, were introduced in 1967 and made through the mid-1980s. The Op lamps, like Op art posters of the time, used principles of physics to create eye dazzling optical illusions with simple geometric patterns. Optical effects were enhanced in the lamps with the added dimension of motion. Production ceased when the plastic used in their manufacture was found to be carcinogenic.
Bases, metal harps, bulb sockets, cylinders, metal fans, outer shades and power cords are virtually identical on new and old. The best feature to identify the new Op lamps is their use of two vertical seams in the cylinder and shade. The same original parts have only one vertical seam. A more subtle difference, but one that is easy to see when the lamps are side by side, is that the new plastics have a slight blue tint.
Also check the plugs; new plugs are marked Taiwan. All the new Op lamp shades are marked "India" in small print in the bottom black border. Finally, all new Op lamp cylinders spin clockwise while most old ones spin counterclockwise.
Original Op lamps start at about $100. The new lamps retail for about the same as the scenic lamps, $30-$40 in shops and catalogs.
When an original Antique Car lamp sells for $350 and a nearly identical reproduction is offered for only $30, there is cause for concern on what effect this may have on the collectibles market. That is why we have gone into considerable detail explaining the differences between new and old. Understanding the differences between the two will help all buyers, collectors or dealers, avoid mistakes.
Buyers need to be especially alert to mismatched and "married" parts. New shades fit on old bases and new cylinders work with old shades.
Don't rely on one test alone to determine age or authenticity. Examine each part of the lamp – shade, cylinder, base, tops and bottoms – separately. If the features of any one part aren't correct, be suspicious of the entire lamp.
Sam and Anna Samuelian Collector's Guide to Motion Lamps features 550 motion lamps in 800 color photos. .