Loading ...
Loading ...

Federal Agents Bust Fake Sports Memorabilia RingBy

Federal Agents Bust Fake Sports Memorabilia Ring

Nationwide Scam May Top $100 million

A federal investigation of fake sports and celebrity autographed memorabilia resulted in the breakup of a network allegedly responsible for selling up to $100 million of fraudulent merchandise.

Over 10,000 baseballs were seized along with bats, hats, helmets, pucks, jerseys, photos, posters and other items. A 10,000 sq. ft. warehouse was rented by authorities to hold all the confiscated goods.

Agents seized the material while executing 60 search warrants at locations in five states: California, New Jersey, Nevada, Pennsylvania and Florida. Over 400 Special Agents of the FBI and IRS were involved in the operation. The value of the forged memorabilia seized is estimated at $10 million.

FBI Agent in Charge Timothy Fitzsimmons of the San Diego office told ACRN in a phone interview that all the persons arraigned so far have been from southern California. "However, the investigation is continuing and we expect more charges to be filed," said Fitzsimmons. "As you can tell from the execution of the search warrants, the investigation is nationwide."

Forged athlete and celebrity autographs found on the various objects seized included: Mother Teresa, President Ronald Reagan, Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, Mickey Mantle, Roberto Clemente, Mark McGwire, Sammy Sosa, and Tony Gwynn.

Also seized were hundreds of "cut signatures", or "cuts" a trade name for famous signatures cut out of documents or letters. Forged cuts which were seized or purchased during the investigation included: George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, Theodore Roosevelt, John F. Kennedy, James Dean, Marilyn Monroe, Elvis Presley, James Cagney, Walt Disney, Charles Chaplin, Ty Cobb, Babe Ruth, Cy Young and Roberto Clemente

The forgers used historically correct ink, writing implements, and paper for the time period the signature was purported to have been made. Old period paper was acquired by tearing blank pages from old books.

In documents related to the investigation, the FBI says many memorabilia experts believe up to ninety percent of autographed celebrity and sports items on the market today are forged. Using these estimates, forgeries may total $500,000,000 to $900,000,000 of the $1 billion memorabilia market.

The FBI offers the following suggestions to avoid buying fake or forged autographed memorabilia.

First, don't be overly impressed by appraisals or certificates of authenticity. Individuals and companies involved with selling forged memorabilia often include some type of Certificate of Authenticity, allegedly from a third party expert. Often, the authenticator is either a knowing, or unknowing but incompetent, participant in the fraud. Carefully read the Certificate of Authenticity, looking for the authentication "language", an address, telephone number and name of the authenticators. Do not accept copies of certificates of authenticity; insist on examining the actual certificate in person.

A photograph of an athlete or celebrity signing an autograph is no guarantee the item is authentic. This investigation revealed that it is a common practice of forged memorabilia traffickers to include a photograph of the athlete/celebrity signing the item along with a Certificate of Authenticity. Traffickers also include photographs of themselves with the athlete/celebrity to lend credibility to their forged memorabilia.

Items represented to be from an individual or company which hired an athlete or celebrity for a paid signing session have no guarantee of authenticity. Agents have discovered it is common practice for forged memorabilia traffickers to mix in forged memorabilia with items signed during legitimate autograph sessions. For example, the forgers may arrange a legitimate contract with an athlete to sign 500 items. After the signing, the company will mix in forgeries with the authentic autographs.

The method of selling memorabilia should not affect a healthy skepticism about the item's authenticity. One such sales method is through charity auctions where buyers often do not question the authenticity of the items. Many buyers frequently overpay for the items as well thinking it will be for a good cause. The unsuspecting charity doesn't realize it has been an unwitting tool in helping the forgers sell their goods.

The seizures and charges were announced April 11, 2000 in San Diego, California and capped a three year investigation.

Real Or Repro is powered by Ruby Lane — the award-winning marketplace trusted by collectors worldwide.

Why Ruby Lane? Winner of multiple Ecommerce Bytes Sellers Choice Awards for Quality, Customer Service, and Most Recommended Selling Venue.

Now that you know what to avoid...

♥️ Find the Real Deal on Ruby Lane

Shop with confidence from our vetted dealers who specialize in authentic vintage and antique treasures.
Nolan Ryan Signature Series Autographed Porcelain Cards (3 Sets /200) #23611
Gold and Silver Brokers
$3,999
Original 1981 MARK HAMILL Autograph w/ Polaroid Photo in our Antique Shop
GreatVintageStuff
$795
Roger Clemens Signed/Autographed Baseball (Upper Deck UDA COA) *1319
Gold and Silver Brokers
$150
. Preakness Program 100 Year Celebration (1975)
Dotty Lee's Treasures
$75
Shaquille O'Neal Harwood Classics Signed/Autographed LA Lakers Jersey #23451
Gold and Silver Brokers
$799
Vintage Celebration! Of American Quilts, Earthenware Tile, “Bride’s Album Quilt” ca. 1993
ModerneAntiques & Collectibles
$20
Johnathan Jessop Federal Tall Case Clock
David Vallone Restorations Inc.
$3,500
Wimbledon Tennis Championships Strawberry Mug
Green Country Estates
$18
Ted Williams Signed/Autographed Baseball Boston Red Sox (Upper Deck Holo) *1284
Gold and Silver Brokers
$499
1969 Team Signed Green Bay Packers Football, Including Bart Starr
New Hampshire Antique Co-op
$1,295
1993-94 Topps Finest Basketball: 31 Cards, 2 Refractors Chris Weber Rookie *1122
Gold and Silver Brokers
$199
Vintage 1997-1998 Upper Deck Collectors Choice Series 1 Basketball Sealed Wax Pack Box Featuring Michael Jordan On Cover Of Box
My Grandmother Had One
$952
$1,190
Joe Namath Signed/Autographed NFL Football New York Jets (CBS LOA) *1180
Gold and Silver Brokers
$399
Reggie Jackson Oakland Athletics (A's) Professional Model Game Jersey #23144
Gold and Silver Brokers
$2,999
NY Giants Stadium Seat Autographed by Lawrence Taylor, Johnson and Banks #23474
Gold and Silver Brokers
$699
Six 1974 Baseball Cards of Batting, Stolen Base, Home Run, Victories, Firemen Featuring HOF Brock, Carew, Schmidt, Allen and Catfish Hunter
Style and Grace
$30
1941 New York Yankees Lou Gehrig Memorial July 4th Ticket Stub PSA Good 2 *1018
Gold and Silver Brokers
$2,999
5 x Vintage Red Leather Hand Stitched Cricket Balls
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$100
1987 Topps “Cal Ripken” Card #784 Print Errors” Thumb Is Pointing up to a crucifix(Cross)
Finds N Trends
$315
Gustave Flaubert Autograph Letter Signed
Avenue Art and Antiques
$585
The Sporting News 1971 Publication – Baltimore Frank Robinson with Autograph
Ogee's Antiques
$32
2025 Topps Elly De La Cruz, Rafael Devers, Billy Williams, Juan Soto Lot #23472
Gold and Silver Brokers
$599
1918 Amateur Base Ball Trophy Watch Fob A J Reach Company Baseball
SS Moore Antiques
$50
Alexander Graham Bell Autographed Letter Signed 1903
Avenue Art and Antiques
$795
Vintage Celebration! Of American Quilts, Earthenware Tile, “Double Wedding Ring” ca. 1992
ModerneAntiques & Collectibles
$20
VINTAGE 80s Kudu RUGBY FOOTBALL New Zealand All Black Signed "Geoff Old" President
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$20
Washington Irving Autographed Letter Signed
Avenue Art and Antiques
$425
Jerry Rice, Football Hall of Fame Wide Receiver for the San Francisco 49ers - Oil on Paper, Illegible Signature
The Marchand-Mercier
$148
$255
Vintage Celebration! Of American Quilts, Earthenware Tile, “Log Cabin, Barn Raising Variation” ca. 1994
ModerneAntiques & Collectibles
$20
1989 Donruss Diamond Kings Ken Griffey Jr #4 Reverse Error
Finds N Trends
$299
Framed Autographed Letter From T.S. Eliot to The Master Pembroke College Cambridge
Fritz Antiques
$1,000
1971-72 Topps Wilt Chamberlain #70 NBA Card Los Angeles Lakers *1167
Gold and Silver Brokers
$99
Frank Thomas Hall of Famer 7 Great Cards
Style and Grace
$100
PSA certified Stan Lee autograph
Centaur Art Galleries
$895
Art Deco Silhouette Print of Celebration.
Emporium, Ltd.
$95
1996 New Old Stock Authentic Atlanta Olympic Games Collection Mens XL Navy Sweater Vest with Tags
Cheries Collectible Treasures
$39
1964, 1966, 1968 Topps Detroit Tigers 20-Card Lot #24495
Gold and Silver Brokers
$175
Autograph Album East Berlin Pennsylvania Dedication August 17, 1883
SS Moore Antiques
$95
Framed Party Picture from New York Autographed by Olympics Champion Mark Spitz
The Marchand-Mercier
$43
$45
Autographed B & W Photo w/Message - “Festus” Ken Curtis Gunsmoke
Bearski Gallery llc
$350
Wright Co. Boston Celebrated Roasted Coffee "Java Blend" Advertising Wall Clock !
Antique Investments
$750
Arnold Palmer Golf Collectible: Sterling Money Clip: Facsimile Autograph
Duchess Arts & Antiques
$125
Mordecai Brown Pitching Piedmont Baseball Card Series
Sweetpea Cottage
$499
Antique Sterling Hand Etched Sculling Medal 1886: pre-olympic caliber
Duchess Arts & Antiques
$695
Antique French Celebration Flag 1818 Regiment Du Genie 1818
Emporium, Ltd.
$2,000
'99 Yankee World Series Team Ball
Emily's Attic, LLC
$855
$1,250
Sinclair Lewis Autographed Letter
Avenue Art and Antiques
$385
First c1950s Baseball Los Angeles Dodgers Crossed Bats Stadium Souvenir Pin Button
GreatVintageStuff
$49
Sir Walter Scott Autograph Document Signed
Avenue Art and Antiques
$695
Yankees Autographed Baseball (JSA: 8 Autos inc. Alex Rodriguez, Mattingly) *1068
Gold and Silver Brokers
$550
Set of Three Team USA 1980 Olympic Embroidered Patches
Bluebonnet Hill Estates & Antiques
$14
Rube “Lefty” Waddell Throwing, Piedmont Baseball Card in St. Louis Jersey
Sweetpea Cottage
$399
X Marks the Spy - Christopher Cool Teen Agent Series
Big-Little Book Emporium
$9
Thornton Wilder Autograph Letter Signed
Avenue Art and Antiques
$175
1926 Sterling and Enamel Football League Medal Fob
Chapel Hill British Charm
$39
$45
Antique c1852 Friendship Album, Autograph Book, Illustrated, Calligraphy Poems
Neatcurios
$85
Vintage Celebration! Of American Quilts, Earthenware Tile, “Eliza Baile’s Bride Quilt” ca. 1996
ModerneAntiques & Collectibles
$50
Donruss 1991 Highlights Nolan Ryan Reverse Triple Error Card #BC-3
Finds N Trends
$295
The Big Dawg's Back - Dale Sr. T-Shirt
Classic Fab Finds
$115
Mariano Rivera Signed/Autographed New York Yankees Cap/Hat (Steiner COA) *1323
Gold and Silver Brokers
$499
Keychain 1988 Seoul Olympics 24kt Gold Plated Original Box
VintageTreasuresFound
$24
Unsigned Federal Period Gilded Front Presentation Banjo Clock with Mahogany Case, Circa 1815 !
Antique Investments
$1,800
Rare Emile Zola Autographed Letter Signed
Avenue Art and Antiques
$745
Art Deco Vintage Bowling Trophy on Butterscotch Bakelite Base – Circa 1930s
KTA LLC
$595
19th Century Signed Autograph Letter Harriet Beecher Stowe 1888
Fritz Antiques
$600
Museum Piece, SEVRES 1924 Paris Olympic Games Gold Medal Vase
Art Deco Ceramic Glass Light
$45,000
Six 1975 Tops Leaders in Home Runs, Stolen Bases, Wins, ERA featuring Lou Brock, Rod Carew, Catfish Hunter and Mike Schmidt
Style and Grace
$25
Vintage 1960s BEATLES Beatle Hair Brush in Original Package
GreatVintageStuff
$185
Canadian Pacific Railway Agent Shield Badge c.1900
The Vintage Crate
$235
Lot Of 21 Michael Jordan R.C., MVP, Promo, Hologram, & Rare Basket/Baseball Cards
Finds N Trends
$4,900
Vintage 1980 Topps Giant Baseball Superstar Photos Sports Card Set
My Grandmother Had One
$29
Antique Cast Iron Hand Forged Dinner Triangle Bell with Hand Forged Hanger
The Vintage Crate
$120
Jose Uribe Triple Error Card D/O/B see listing
Finds N Trends
$45
Vintage Original Autographs Bobby Vinton Vera Ralston Olympia Dukakis Dr. Faerstein
GreatVintageStuff
$95
Vintage Horse Brass Medallion
Twin Pines Estate Sales
$28
Dorothy Hamill Signed Autographed To Eric US Olympic Figure Skater
Gumgumfuninthesun
$94
1933 Sterling & Enamel Trophy Medal / Pin Rifle Match
KLMAntiques
$95
Agate Watch Fob With BYU Sports Medals 1935 - 1941
Copperton Lane Antiques and Collectibles
$50
Robert F. Kennedy Signed/Autographed Presidential Program (JSA LOA) *1066
Gold and Silver Brokers
$1,999
1910 Dial Lodge Princeton University Pool Loving Cup Trophy
Evia Antiques and art
$275
Stone Cold Steve Austin Signed/Autographed 16x20 (Steiner Sports COA) #23477
Gold and Silver Brokers
$425
Topps Joe Namath In Action 1972 Card #343
Style and Grace
$125
Scottish Golf Medallion Medal – St. Andrews Golf Club – 1914 – Sterling – Fully Hallmarked
Kate's Classic Costume Jewelry
$385
Hamilton Fish American Statesman Autograph Letter Signed
Avenue Art and Antiques
$95
Antique Sterling and Enamel Football Fob
Chapel Hill British Charm
$56
$65
Original Autographed MISS PIGGY Bodybuilding Workout Photo to Me - Framed
GreatVintageStuff
$235
Original EDDIE FISHER Autographed Photo to Director Steve Binder
GreatVintageStuff
$89
1927 Vintage Sports Medal - Track and Field 440 Run with Sprinter
Ogee's Antiques
$20
1969 Original JULIAN BOND Autographed Letter House of Reps Ga.
GreatVintageStuff
$55
Vintage Young BROOKE SHIELDS Autographed Photo
GreatVintageStuff
$95