Loading ...
Loading ...

Confusing Tin CowboysBy

Confusing Tin Cowboys

A new metal Roy Rogers windup toy is a close copy of a series of vintage cowboy character toys first introduced in 1938. The original windup horse and rider toy was made by the American toy company of Louis Marx. Action in both new and old toys is the same. Horizontal arms in the base rock the toy forward and back while the lasso spins around the cowboys' heads.

Original toys were made in two licensed character variations, Hopalong Cassidy (shown in Fig. 2) and The Lone Ranger. A generic cowboy figure Marx named Range Rider was also produced.

A variation of the basic design used the same dies to make a freestanding horse and rider without the rocking base. You can distinguish original freestanding figures from figures originally mounted to rocker bases by the location of the Marx trademark. On original rocker base toys, the Marx trademark is on the horizontal surface of the base directly below the horse's tail. On original freestanding toys, the Marx trademark appears on the horse. If you find a horse and rider alone with no trademark, it was most likely originally attached to rocker base.

Although the new toy with Roy Rogers' name is virtually identical in size, actions and shape to Marx originals, a vintage Roy Rogers version of this toy was never made by Marx. The first toy in this shape to carry the Roy Rogers name is this new reproduction.

The new Roy Rogers version is made in China for Schylling Toys, an American toy company. The base of new toys is permanently marked with the Schylling trademark of a running child.

New Roy Rogers toys sell for $25-$30 retail. Original Hopalong Cassidy and Lone Ranger rocker versions sell for about $450-$550 in very good condition. Freestanding versions usually bring $200-$300.

When handled in person, there is probably little chance this toy easily be mistaken for old. But viewed online it might be mistaken for a vintage piece if the buyer isn't aware no vintage Roy Rogers version was ever made.

Suggested reading: Felbinger, L. The Lone Ranger, 1998, and: Coyle, P. Roy Rogers and Dale Evans Toys and Memorabilia, 2000.

Image

Fig. 1 New Roy Rogers tin windup toy is marked Schylling Toys.

Image

Figs. 2-4
Fig. 2 (Left) Original tin windup figure by Louis Marx, ca. 1938. This is Hopalong Cassidy. No Roy Rogers version was ever made by Marx. All Roy Rogers toys like this are new. Fig. 3 (Center) Original versions of these toys have the Marx trademark which includes Made in USA. The trademark appears on the horizontal surface of the rocker base version and on the horse in the freestanding version. Fig. 4 (Right) The freestanding version of the horse and rider, without the rocking base, has the Marx trademark on the horse.

Real Or Repro is powered by Ruby Lane — the award-winning marketplace trusted by collectors worldwide.

Why Ruby Lane? Winner of multiple Ecommerce Bytes Sellers Choice Awards for Quality, Customer Service, and Most Recommended Selling Venue.

Now that you know what to avoid...

♥️ Find the Real Deal on Ruby Lane

Shop with confidence from our vetted dealers who specialize in authentic vintage and antique treasures.
Marx Tin Litho Large Cat Toy
Arlene Rabin Antiques
$150
Mid Century MARX Pressed Steel Toy Row Boat 9 1/2" Long
Patricia Funt Antiques
$48
Marx Commodore Vanderbilt Train Set
Antiquefreak's
$55
Vintage Marx Lithograph Wind-Up Fire Chief Car
The Vintage Crate
$165
Miniature c1960 Marx ELM Disney Pluto Sports Car Rare w/ Original Box
GreatVintageStuff
$68
Complete Mother Goose's Fairykins Story Book by Louis Marx Toys (1962)
Straw Bear Antique Shop
$175
Vintage Marx Toys Mickey Mouse Bendable Arms/Legs Toy
Oldeclectics
$19
$25
Cowboy Whoopee Car Wind-up Toy by Louis Marx & Co.
Urban Fine Art and Antiques
$275
Vintage Marx Pressed Steel Coca-Cola Truck in Rare Grey Color
The Vintage Crate
$435
Dual Horse & Cart Wind-Up Toy by Louis Marx & Co.
Urban Fine Art and Antiques
$250
Marx Pretty Maid Tin Toy Stove with Utensils
Maude's Vintage Ware
$32
$40
Six Marx Soldiers of Fortune Less Common Figures
Great Finds
$65
11" Long Marx Tin Litho Toytown Wind-Up Dairy Cart Horse & Carriage
Oldeclectics
$157
$165
Vintage Original 1960's Marx Toy Company Walt Disney Mickey Mouse Top Hat Magician Head Nodder
My Grandmother Had One
$15
$16
1930s Daisy Buck Rogers Pop Gun in Working Condition
The Vintage Crate
$420
1940's Marx Junior Dial Toy Typewriter
Oldeclectics
$35
Marx Honeymoon Express Vintage Tin Litho Wind-up Toy
Great Finds
$95
Vintage Marx Walk-A-Way Baby Toy
Oldeclectics
$34
$35
1930's Large Pressed Steel Lockeed Sirius Airplane (Electric Lights Version)
Chippewa Lake Antiques
$500
Marx Toy Tin Ice Truck
Antiquefreak's
$55
Vintage Marx Mortimer Snerd Tin Wind Up Crazy Car
The Vintage Crate
$375
Harmony Kingdom Madame Justine, Clair de Lune Series Limited Edition, Adult Version
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$35
$75
Fort Apache Sears Heritage Play Set
Lady Lavender Antiques
$139
Vintage Original 1969-1971 Marx Toy Company Assorted Die Cast Sports Racing Cars Featuring Lola GT Ford GT Ford J Uno Ferrari
My Grandmother Had One
$26
$32
Rare 1952 Marx circus with the circus train cages
Winstonknolls Emporium
$375
Harmony Kingdom Swamp Song Alligators, Treasure Jest First Version
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$30
$48
Educational Base Ten Blocks - b
Hodge Podge Lodge - 1
$26
1965 Marx Toys 20" 333 Whistling Locomotive with Clanging Bell in Soft Red Plastic Toy VGC
JP Things Antiques & Collectibles
$20
Vintage 1950's Marx No. 904 Tin Litho Toy Climbing Tractor
My Grandmother Had One
$72
Harmony Kingdom Bamboozled Panda Treasure Jest, Vintage Colorful Version
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$36
$68
Large Marx Tin Zippo the Monkey Climbing Toy
Antiquefreak's
$75
Vintage Harmony Kingdom Cat Turdus Felidae Treasure Jest, Bird and Mouse, Version One
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$38
$58
The Christmas Treasure Book Arranged by Hilda Marx Hardback book
Eastside Collectiques of TN
$38
$44
1930's Marx Windup G-Man Automatic with Key Working with Sparks
The Vintage Crate
$110
Military Hap & Hop Ramp Walker Toy by Louis Marx Co.
Fenwood Studio
$15
$25
Louis Marx Electric Phonograph Toy Record Player
Rare Finds
$60
Mini Tootsietoy Diecast Cars, Firebird, MG, More & Hong Kong Marx Volkswagon
Glory Bee Estate Finds
$48
Harmony Kingdom Tea For Two Walrus Couple, Vintage Treasure Jest, Rare Version
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$38
$70
Antique German Erzgebirge Wooden Toy Set – 42 Pieces – Village, Park & Zoological Garden – Original Storage Box – ca. 1900–1930
La Tresorerie
~$712
Rare Chinese/English Version of Coca Cola Bottle
Finds N Trends
$79
$99
Harmony Kingdom Madame Josephine, Clair de Lune Series Limited Edition, Adult Version
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$35
$75
Harmony Kingdom Madame Kiki, Clair de Lune Series Limited Edition, Adult Version
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$35
$75
Harmony Kingdom Croc Pot Crocodiles, Version Two, Treasure Jest
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$35
$56
Marx Pressed Steel Marcrest Dairy Stake Truck- Repainted
The Vintage Crate
$355
Forest and Stream Pocket Tobacco Tin – Fisherman Version with Creel Top
The Vintage Crate
$285
Vintage 1980's PEZ Toy Candy Dispenser Version E Featuring Disney's Donald Duck
My Grandmother Had One
$12
$15
Harmony Kingdom Croc Pot Crocodiles, Rare Version One, Treasure Jest Vintage
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$35
$56
Bugatti Race Car by Marx
Why? Why Not
$35
Marx tin litho honeymoon express train
Harmon Antique Sales.
$120
$128
Boyds Bears Folkstone Angel of Peace 1E Original Version, Rare Hard to Find Collectible
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$25
Tonka State Hi-Way Dept Hydraulic Dump Truck, 1957
Lady Lavender Antiques
$399
Vintage Marx Toy Battleship Tin Litho 14 1/2"
Antiques Of River Oaks
$195
Milky Cow General Mills Toy
Antiquefreak's
$65
Harmony Kingdom SIGNING LINE Atlanta 2000, Three Cherries Version, Very Rare Limited Edition
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$150
German Pull Toy Animal on Wooden Base
Antiquefreak's
$75
Harmony Kingdom Dolphin On A Roll, Treasure Jest, Rare Early Version, Calvesbert
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$35
$65
Tiny Antique Well Loved Super Primitive Straw Mohair Stuffed Cat
Albion Valley Folk Art and Antiques
$64
$165
Mighty Tonka Big Yellow Metal Dump Truck 1970s
Copperton Lane Antiques and Collectibles
$50
Darling Vintage Velvet Dog Pull Toy w/Shoe Button Eyes
Albion Valley Folk Art and Antiques
$128
$175
Original 1954 Lady and the Tramp Animation Cels. 2084 Cinescope version.
Treasure Hunter
$3,995
A rare kakelorum marble 'gambling' game, 19th Century
The Toy Shop
~$800
1956 Roy Rogers Trigger Metal Lunchbox
The Vintage Crate
$170
Vintage Queen Cast Iron Toy Stove
The Vintage Crate
$110
Vintage Mixed 1950’s-1960’s Marx Toy Company Plastic Prehistoric Dinosaur Set
My Grandmother Had One
$48
Antique Early 1900's 20" Tall Mohair Horse Platform Pull Toy from my Collection
Albion Valley Folk Art and Antiques
$362
$425
Vintage Marx Tin Lithographed Tank Corps 3 Wind Up Tank Toy- Mech Works but Slipping
The Vintage Crate
$205
11" Circa 1940's German made Teddy Bear MINT
Lana & Esther's Dolls, Bears & ETC
$220
1956 Roy Rogers and the Indian Sign Little Golden Book
Joyland
$50
Harmony Kingdom Angel Treasure Jest Joie de Vivre, Angelique Rare Color Version
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$20
$48
Britains Boxed Set 1476 Coronation Display 1937-1941
Great Finds
$650
Mennonite Horse Pull Toy Antique
Avenue Art and Antiques
$195
A antique/vintage possibel Moritz Goldschalk Wooden Medieval Toy Castle Fort Dollhouse
La Tresorerie
~$244
Playmobil Circus #4230 & 4231
Hodge Podge Lodge - 1
$100
Antique Stereoscope & 17 Stereograph Cards
Elaine's Antique Emporium
$120
R. Crumb's Head Comix Softcover 1988 Version *1267
Gold and Silver Brokers
$65
Mark & Carol Reynolds Kaleidovisions Signed Inlaid Wood Kaleidoscope w/ Stand
VP Accents
$295
Antique Chinese Carved Cinnabar Lacquer Vase with Blue Enamel Interior and Base
Nicer Than New
$149
Antique French Teddy Bear 13"
La farandolls
$180
Vintage Little Giant Toy Zeppelin Blimp Large 25"
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$298
Goofy with Wheelbarrow Plastic Wind up toy Marx for Disney
Great Finds
$25
50's Frankenstein’s Hand Mystery Bank Nomura TN Japanese Litho Wind Up Tin Toy
Antique Matchmaker
$120
$149
Vintage 1950s Hubley Atomic Disintegrator Space Pistol Toy
The Vintage Crate
$625
Art Deco Vintage Bowling Trophy on Butterscotch Bakelite Base – Circa 1930s
KTA LLC
$595
Harmony Kingdom Swap 'n Sell Treasure Jest, Fig Leaf Version, 1999 Limited Edition, Signed
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$95
Karl Marx Commemorative Token
Treasure Hut
$60
Chinese Mid Century Carved Rosewood Base / Stand
Basingers Vintage Collectibles and Fashions
$45
Dear Vintage Blue Faux Fur Stuffed Rabbit
Albion Valley Folk Art and Antiques
$26
$48
1920s or 30s Wooden 2 Drawer Doll Dresser with Swivel Mirror
Joyland
$65
Rare 1866 Antique Milton Bradley Myriopticon Historical Panorama - Rebellion - Civil War
Moore & Moore Antiques
$950
Coca Cola Musical Coin Bank
Dotty Lee's Treasures
$75