Loading ...
Loading ...

Confusing New Deco ShakerBy

Confusing New Deco Shaker - $48 Copy Mistaken for $1000 Original

A highly sought after Art Deco figural cocktail shaker, the Napier Penguin, has been reproduced. Originals have sold for as much as $1400; the new reproduction originally cost $48.

Collectible bar ware specialist Stephen Visakay told ACRN in a telephone interview, that unsuspecting buyers have paid $200-$300 and more for the reproductions. "One sold on an Internet auction site for over $300," said Visakay. "The seller included some remarks about "some areas of light wear" and "minor scratches" to make the new shaker appear convincing." Visakay, author of Vintage Bar Ware1, described several ways to authenticate an original Napier Penguin.

In the original Penguin shaker by Napier, the entire beak is hinged (Fig. 2, arrow) at the face. This lifts up to reveal a stopper and pouring spout. The beak on the reproduction is not hinged; there is a screw on metal stopper at the end of the beak.

The original is silver plate over metal; the new piece is nickel plate on metal. An authentic Napier Penguin is stamped in the base "Napier–pat. pending" or "Napier–pat D 101559" (see patent drawing, Fig. 3). New shakers do not have a permanent mark. They arrive with only a removable paper label reading "Made in India" applied to the base.

Visakay said original Napier Penguin shakers sell for $750-$1400. Average price for an authentic piece with silver plating in good condition is currently about $1000. The Napier Penguin was introduced during the holiday season of 1936. It retailed for $12.50 at gift shops and fine department stores. The Napier Company was a jewelry manufacturer in Meriden, Connecticut. When prohibition was repealed in 1932, it decided to expand into bar ware.

The new shaker is promoted as a copy of the "1936 Napier Penguin" by a mail order firm specializing in reproductions. New shakers began appearing late 1998.

Visakay said there is also a "old" knockoff of the Napier Penguin made about 1938. In that version, the wings are embossed in the body, not separate; the beak is not hinged and there is no Napier mark. The 1938 knockoffs sell for $200-$300.

1Vintage Bar Ware by Stephen Visakay, Collector Books.

image

Fig. 1 (New) Beak of reproduction has only a screw on stopper; beak is not hinged. New shaker is nickel plated metal, no permanent mark.

image

Fig. 2 (Old) Original Napier Penguin cocktail shaker, ca. 1936. Entire beak is hinged (white arrow). Original is silver plated and always permanently marked in base.

Photo: Vintage Bar Ware by Stephen Visakay, © 1997 Collector Books

image

Fig. 3 Patent drawing for original Napier Penguin shaker. Filed in October of 1936.

Real Or Repro is powered by Ruby Lane — the award-winning marketplace trusted by collectors worldwide.

Why Ruby Lane? Winner of multiple Ecommerce Bytes Sellers Choice Awards for Quality, Customer Service, and Most Recommended Selling Venue.

Now that you know what to avoid...

♥️ Find the Real Deal on Ruby Lane

Shop with confidence from our vetted dealers who specialize in authentic vintage and antique treasures.
Rare Beak Beanie Baby with Tag
My Favorite Vintage
$125
Mid Century Heron Bird Salt & Pepper Shakers Gold-tone Beaks Ceramic
Gumgumfuninthesun
$20
Adorable 1930's Colorful Long Beaked Bird Salt and Pepper Shaker MIJ
JP Things Antiques & Collectibles
$12
Inuit Carved Stone Penguin w/ Young - Sculpture - 14” Tall
Bearski Gallery llc
$6,500
Vintage Wolf Sculptures Original Penguin Figurine, 2.5” (H), Canada
Rusty Husky Antiques
$15
1988 Franklin Mint Hand Painted Porcelain We Four Penguin Family Sculpture Figurine
Cheries Collectible Treasures
$40
Vintage Hazel Atlas Rooster Cocktail Shaker Set
Pigeon Squared
$195
Tomi Leather Toy Penguin
The Museum Doll Shop
$60
Caramel Bakelite Chicken Napking Ring with Brown Beak
Turtle Creek Antiques, Inc.
$68
1985 Hand Painted Franklin Mint Porcelain "Whoops" Penguin Sculpure Figurine
Cheries Collectible Treasures
$28
Blown German Mercury Glass Penguin 5 Inches
Copperton Lane Antiques and Collectibles
$99
RARE Napier Small Cocktail Shaker - Dial-a-Drink - Silver Plated -Mid 1930's
Patricia Funt Antiques
$175
$275
Shaker Style Round Wood Box
BeJewelled
$28
Novelty Toy Penguin Water Gun Pistol
Glory Bee Estate Finds
$18
Italian DeNoel Penguin Christmas Ornament
Colemans Collectibles
$35
Antique Mughal Maharajas Bronze Swan Ewer Deccani Hamsa Aquamanile
JewelryGemCollections
$9,900
$12,000
Oneida Penguin Ceramic Cookie Jar
Copperton Lane Antiques and Collectibles
$45
Wide Eye Deer Shakers - b327
Hodge Podge Lodge - 1
$12
Solid Brass Penguin 2 1/2" Tall
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$11
Vintage Crown Toy Company Penguin Bank
Andover Attic
$60
19thc Carved Coquilla Nut Shaker Egg
Forget Me Not Antiques
$55
Lenox Lido Salt Shaker and Pepper Mill
Brass Pineapple Antiques and Estates
$75
Mid Century Cocktail Shaker with Recipes
Patricia Funt Antiques
$48
Vintage Napier Silver Plate Bar Jigger Measure Valve Jigger Mechanical
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$60
Black matte swan porcelain figurine with a gold beak, Hollohaza, Hungary.
Prohibition Gems
~$73
Vintage Bell Boy Salt & Pepper Shaker
Oldeclectics
$65
Vintage French PENGUIN Pen Holder Onyx Base
The Frame Lady
$125
WHIMSICAL Vintage 1930s 40s ART DECO Carved & Painted Bakelite PENGUIN Desktop Letter Holder PAPERWEIGHT
California Dreaming - Modern & Wearable Art
$597
$795
Harmony Kingdom Murphy Penguin Pendant, Rosemont 2002 Expo, Limited Edition Rare
Fortune Gallery of Vintage Collectibles
$30
$35
1900's Small Leather Shaker Sewing Kit
Forget Me Not Antiques
$85
Homer Laughlin Fiestaware Salt And Pepper Shaker Set
Colemans Collectibles
$45
Britains Ltd Vintage Penguin Lead Metal Figure and Bunny Snails Worm Turtle Mouse
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$16
Shawnee Pottery Smiley And Winnie Salt And Pepper Shakers
Colemans Collectibles
$45
Cocktail shaker
The R & J Collection
$80
Mid Century Norcrest Cat Salt & Pepper Shakers Squeakers Japan
Gumgumfuninthesun
$74
Sabathday Lake Shaker Half Round Poplar Ware Box Signed
Appaloosa Antiques
$195
1987 Franklin Mint Hand Painted Whee! Penguin Porcelain Sculpture Figurine
Cheries Collectible Treasures
$28
Fern Opalescent Cranberry Glass Salt and Pepper Shakers
Blu Herons Pond Vintage
$73
$90
Vintage Miniature Solid Brass Penguin
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$19
Boleslawiec Polish Salt and Pepper Shakers
Colemans Collectibles
$16
Owens-Illinois Forest Green Glass Waffle Pattern Shaker Jar
Bluebonnet Hill Estates & Antiques
$19
Very Rare Kitchen Pixie Salt and Pepper Shakers
Gumgumfuninthesun
$120
Cool Pair! Vintage BAKELITE Penguin Salt & Pepper Shakers
Cribtoy's Closet
$229
Two Vintage Penguin Gourd Figures Signed 10 1/2" Tall
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$22
Corelle Snowflake Blue Garland Salt Pepper Shakers by Gemco
Copperton Lane Antiques and Collectibles
$25
Ham Sandwich Shakers - b327
Hodge Podge Lodge - 1
$10
January 23, 2000, TY Retired 'Frigid the Penguin' Beanie Baby
Precious Memories Antiques
$25
Out of Round Shaker Bentwood Horsehair Sifter Sieve
Bluebonnet Hill Estates & Antiques
$76
$84
Vintage Metal Salt And Pepper Shakers
Heritage Oaks of Calabasas
$14
1920’s Watrous Sterling Silver Salt & Pepper Shakers
Pigeon Squared
$135
Ziggy Poster Ziggy on Iceberg with Penguins Tom Willson Signed Limited Edition
Gumgumfuninthesun
$299
1989 Franklin Mint "Watch Me" Hand Painted Porcelain Penguin Sculpture Figurine
Cheries Collectible Treasures
$40
Augarten Porcelain Factory Figure of 2 Penguins, 1930, Austria
Thomas L Stewart
$495
Vintage Primitive Hand Painted Wood Animal Toy Figures Lion Penguin Bear Buffalo
Gumgumfuninthesun
$34
Shaker Oval Pantry Box
Avenue Art and Antiques
$425
Signed Sabbathday Lake Shaker Sewing Stand
Appaloosa Antiques
$275
Vintage Art Deco Sheffield Silver Plated Martini Cocktail Shaker Pitcher Barware
Antique Matchmaker
$156
$195
WONDERFUL Authentic Vintage Iconic RCA Victor Nipper the Dog Porcelain Salt and Pepper Shakers
Vintage Things
$145
Vintage Cobalt Blue Light Bulb Salt and Pepper Shakers
Bluebonnet Hill Estates & Antiques
$19
Early Out-of-Round Shaker Bentwood Horsehair Sifter Sieve
Bluebonnet Hill Estates & Antiques
$97
$107
Vintage Mid Century Modern Hand Carved Wood Salt and Pepper Shakers Sculptural Pair
Lamps & Lagniappe
$57
$85
Pewter Perched Bird Salt and Pepper Shakers
Treasure Hut
$40
1920’s Shaker Sweetgrass Pin Cushion
Forget Me Not Antiques
$45
Late 1800s Antique Shaker Applecore Thread Spool
Red Moon Antiques
$90
Neiman Marcus Gift Box Shape Salt & Pepper Shakers Silver Gold Plated Set
Van De Shoppe
$175
Vintage Friar Tuck Goebel MONK Salt & Pepper Shakers in Basket W. Germany
GreatVintageStuff
$68
Angel Baby on Swan Salt and Pepper Shakers 1940s
Gumgumfuninthesun
$65
Vintage Large Rooster Salt and Pepper Shakers
My Grandmother Had One
$10
$20
Antique Oval Bentwood Pantry Box Shaker Style Primitive Early American Wooden Treen Storage Box
SS Moore Antiques
$95
Vintage West Bend Chrome Penguin Ice Bucket, MCM Hot/Cold Holder (1950s-60s)
Black Dawg Mercantile
$40
MCM Rooster Chicken Orange and Gold Salt Pepper Shakers Ceramic
Gumgumfuninthesun
$28
Lefton Salt & Pepper Shakers Christmas Tree Noel Mid Century
Gumgumfuninthesun
$70
Jim Shore Angels Salt And Pepper Shakers
Colemans Collectibles
$18
Carnival Penguin Glow in the Dark Christmas Ornament Hard Plastic by Rosbro
SS Moore Antiques
$35
Antique Book King Penguin by Richard Horne Published by MacMillan
My Grandmother Had One
$40
$76
Lords Prayer Salt and Pepper Shakers
Gumgumfuninthesun
$18
Vintage Shaker G. L. Cook & Co. New Haven Wooden Berry Basket
Black Tulip Antiques, Ltd.
$125
Vintage McKee Jadeite Glass Art Deco Roman Arch Sugar Shaker
Blu Herons Pond Vintage
$73
Dorothy Kindell Nude Women Salt and Pepper Shakers Signed New Mexico Souvenir
Gumgumfuninthesun
$48
Stunning Cocktail Shaker Crystal and Chrome
Patricia Funt Antiques
$275
Lefton Cat Kitty with Package Salt Shaker Figurine Replacement
Gumgumfuninthesun
$24
Toast and Toaster Salt and Pepper Shakers - b327
Hodge Podge Lodge - 1
$10
Napco Christmas Santa Claus and Mrs. Claus Salt & Pepper Shakers
Gumgumfuninthesun
$39
Set of Vintage Jadeite Salt and Pepper Shakers With Scotty Dog
Neetiques
$69
Antique Bentwood Pantry Box Shaker Folk Art Rustic C 1850
Trinity Antiques
$245
Vintage Salt & Pepper Shakers
Finds N Trends
$13
2 Vintage Bakelite Figural Mini Solid Perfume Rouge Pot Jars Penguin & Man
Cribtoy's Closet
$350
Shaker Goods Alfred Maine Sewing Basket Bentwood Oval Work Basket with Miniature Baskets
SS Moore Antiques
$195
Strapless. JOHN SINGER SARGENT and the Fall of Madame X by Deborah Davis. First Edition. 2003. Pub. by Penguin Group. Illustrated Hardcover. Mint Condition.
Books and Bygones
$23
$25
Antique Victorian Period Brass Hand Crafted Salt & Pepper Shaker
My Grandmother Had One
$71
$78